Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Is Retro Killing Innovation? Limiting Effects on Indie Music

In recent years, the indie music scene has witnessed a resurgence of retro aesthetics, with artists drawing inspiration from past decades to shape their sound and visual identity. While this nostalgic revival has undoubtedly produced some captivating music, there’s a growing concern that the overemphasis on retro trends could be stifling creativity within the indie music landscape.

In this article, we’ll explore how the retro trend in indie music may be restricting artistic innovation and originality.

What is Retro?

Retro, short for retrospective, refers to a cultural phenomenon characterized by a revival or reimagining of styles, aesthetics, and trends from the past. Think of it as a nostalgic revival that tries to evoke a sense of familiarity and sentimentality, tapping into the collective memory of audiences while infusing a contemporary twist.

In music, this involves artists drawing inspiration from previous decades, incorporating elements of vintage sounds, instrumentation, and visual aesthetics into their work.

Looking back is innate to human nature, especially when things aren’t turning up the way we’d like to in the present. Well, like in any other art form, we sometimes look back to find inspiration in musical gems like these:

Read that again: inspiration. The point of inspiration is to use the past as a motor to “invent” or “create” something; this implies newness, innovation, etc. When we enter the loop of recreation or reinvention, we risk losing ourselves in a musical routine and, therefore, killing creativity.

Retro Effects on Indie Music

Although we’ll provide examples of artists who have managed to stay original while looking back, this trend may also pose challenges and limitations to artistic creativity and innovation.

Look Back with an Eye on the Road

One of the primary criticisms of the retro trend is its tendency to prioritize nostalgia over innovation. As artists strive to recreate the sounds and styles of previous eras, there’s a risk of regurgitating familiar tropes rather than pushing the boundaries of musical experimentation.

While paying homage to musical influences is a longstanding tradition in the industry, excessively clinging to the past can hinder the development of fresh and distinctive voices.

Respect the Genre with a Different Sound

Another effect is the standardization of sound within the indie music scene. As more and more artists gravitate towards similar retro-inspired aesthetics, there’s a danger of a “one-size-fits-all” approach to music production.

This standardization can result in a lack of diversity and originality, as artists feel pressured to conform to established norms rather than carving out their own unique sonic identity.

Be Inspired by the Past, Create for the Present

While retro aesthetics may hold nostalgic appeal for some listeners, they may also fail to resonate with younger audiences who crave music that reflects their own cultural experiences and sensibilities.

By fixating on the past, indie musicians risk alienating potential fans who are seeking music that speaks to the contemporary issues and concerns of the present day.

In an increasingly diverse and interconnected world, there’s a need for music that reflects the richness and complexity of modern life, rather than simply rehashing the past.

Break Tradition to Evolve

Perhaps the major risk is how it can obstacle musical progression and evolution. True innovation usually emerges from a need to break free from the constraints of tradition and chart new creative territory.

By keeping a tunnel vision on retro aesthetics, you might fall into a repetitive cycle that makes it impossible to break the sonic frontier, push genre boundaries, and inevitably, fully express yourself.

Retro Indie Music: Original Artists

Luckily, we have plenty of examples of indie artists who have managed to look back while keeping an eye on the present and future of music.

Back to the 70s

One example of retro music in indie music inspired by the 1970s is the band Tame Impala. While their sound incorporates various elements and isn’t solely focused on replicating the 1970s style, their music often draws inspiration from that era, particularly psychedelic rock, and pop.

Tame Impala, led by Kevin Parker, infuses their music with swirling synths, groovy basslines, and hazy vocals reminiscent of bands like Pink Floyd and The Beatles. Their use of vintage-style production techniques, such as analog recording equipment and tape echo effects, contributes to the retro vibe of their music.

Songs like “Let It Happen” showcase Tame Impala’s knack for crafting catchy melodies and hypnotic grooves while paying homage to the psychedelic sound of the 1970s. Overall, their music is a perfect example of how a musician can draw inspiration from the past while putting their modern spin on it.

Back to the 80s

While the band’s name is a clear nod to the 70s, The 1975 music often incorporates elements from the 80s, especially synth-pop and new wave. The band’s frontman, Matty Healy, has cited artists from the 1980s like Michael Jackson, Prince, and Peter Gabriel as influences, and their music often pays homage to the synth-driven pop of that era.

That’s why you’ll find lush synthesizers and catchy hooks from the 80s pop scene in their sound. For example, songs like “Chocolate” showcase their fondness for blending modern indie sensibilities with retro aesthetics, creating a nostalgically fresh sound. Overall, they’ve managed to create music that appeals to fans of the 80s and modern pop.

Back to the 90s

A great example of retro music from the 1990s influencing indie music today is “Beach House.” While their sound isn’t a direct replication of 90s music, they include elements from that era, particularly dream pop and shoegaze.

Beach House’s music often features ethereal vocals, atmospheric synths, and reverb-drenched guitars reminiscent of the dreamy soundscapes popularized by bands like My Bloody Valentine and Slowdive in the 90s.

Songs like “Space Song” showcase their ability to create immersive sonic landscapes that take you on a dreamy and nostalgic trip while staying rooted in today’s music scene.

Back to the 00s

Is the 00s considered retro? If you’re from Gen Z, the answer is a clear “Yes”. If you were born earlier, the answer is still “Yes”, but hurts a bit more.

Yes, it’s none other than the Arctic Monkeys. This band emerged as a prominent indie rock band in the mid-2000s, their music has often drawn influence from the post-punk revival and garage rock revival of that era.

Arctic Monkeys’ early albums, such as Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not (2006) and Favourite Worst Nightmare (2007) feature energetic guitar-driven songs with catchy hooks and sharp lyrics. Their sound reflects the indie rock resurgence of the 2000s, which was characterized by a return to more straightforward rock arrangements and a rejection of the polished production values of mainstream pop.

Songs like “I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor” evidence their signature anthemic tracks that capture the spirit of mid-2000s indie rock. While their music is firmly rooted in the sounds of their era, it also pays homage to earlier rock traditions, drawing on influences from bands like The Strokes and The Libertines.

They’re a definite bridge between the indie rock of the 2000s and the broader rock traditions that preceded it, making them a key example of how retro influences from the 2000s continue to shape indie music today.

Retro: Back to The Future

Retro, characterized by a revival of styles and trends from the past, can indeed serve as a wellspring of inspiration; however, the retro trend in indie music poses challenges and limitations to artistic originality and innovation. By excessively prioritizing nostalgia, artists may regurgitate familiar tropes rather than pushing the boundaries of musical experimentation.

While drawing inspiration from the past is valuable, artists must also remain focused on creating music that is fresh, relevant, and reflective of the richness and complexity of modern life. Artists like Tame Impala, The 1975, Beach House, and Arctic Monkeys demonstrate how to incorporate retro influences while maintaining originality and relevance in today’s indie music landscape.

Be the first to receive updates
on our blog content